Ok. All good reasonable points. I have been an AOPA member until renewal came up last month.
maybe I will re-up. maybe.
I LOVE and have always felt very indebted to the ASF arm of AOPA. Too bad they don't do the traveling license
test seminars that they once did. That is now replaced by for profit outfits like the Kings ( don't get me started on them).
The wings seminars I have been to in the last years have been fairly uniformly mediocre things rushed through by the presenters, and in the case of the Chart Challenge.. basically crap as presented.
Certainly you are right, AOPA and EAA are the only effective voices we have RE: legislation.
There is a good reason EAA is on the rise and AOPA aint. Neither are or can be all things to all people, despite their marketing.
My problem with AOPA is political and cultural. Naturally there are even fewer left leaning pilots than there are black women pilots. So, it's a personal problem of mine.
They adopted under the last head of AOPA a strident right wing paranoid NRA kind of rhetoric that I find offensive
and slightly lulu - just as most folks find the NRA rhetoric lulu. ( I say this as a person who has had guns since I was a kid).
I don't think we need ak-47s freely distributed and I don't think people who have serious medical issues should be flying airplanes. In the middle ground of implementing common sense almost everybody can be happy.. non flyer's included.
My other problem with AOPA is that it is a very closely held private company - like AAA insurance - with a lot of puffery
making it seem like a "member organization". You join and you are automatically voting for a fixed slate of proxies .
However, there is nobody else providing the kind of info on FAA approved and non-approved RX medication, or with such a fine set of on line Tutorials . I used these heavily getting licensed after not flying for 35+ years... and I constantly recommend AOPA resources to other pilots.. use of which generally means joining.
So, sure. I appreciate them. Kinda.
Also, it was clear to me 5 years ago that by not attacking the 1320 lb weight limit for LSA's... AOPA had completely abandoned the FBO's, Flight Schools, Mechanics, and Owners of Cessna 150's and 152's which are a fleet of 15,000+ aircraft -
now going to hell - that have been rendered nearly worthless and unsellable when a 1650 or 1670 lb limit would have that fleet flying like mad, and mechanics employed working on them.
$100,000 LSA are and were a lead brick.. $15,000 LSA's are not, especially when they are as familiar and well supported with spare parts as the Cessna 150 .
This is the Giant Elephant in the Room... which that bunch of Beltway Suits at AOPA couldn't see if it bit them, crushed them, and gave birth on the front lawn. ( see larry I got in touch with my feelings..)
Maybe they have been working on this - sideways- but this one small change could have done a LOT to stem the obvious collapse of GA including entry into training and ownership.. and could have been done by now.

:mrgreen: