My fuel / gear placard looks like yours. After your success, I ordered a new one (which hasn't arrived yet), guess I'll be in sending it back...
When I ordered my control wheel emblems a couple years ago, it was part #195161 and they were $28.75 each. Looked like the picture below. They're still in good shape; happy to take better photos if someone can find a shop to make replicas.
Speaking of replicas, due to stupidity on my part, I cracked the lighting placard (the silk screened acrylic overlay) while replacing a rheostat. Alexandria couldn't find any more in stock and didn't offer to make one. The part doesn't look that complicated for someone with half an ability in working with plastics; anyone have recommendations for a shop that might be able to build a new one (including the printing)?